Thanks! Yes the plaster was atleast 5 years old, and despite leaving it for weeks in the summer to cure, it's still very soft and i can scratch bits off with a fingernail easily. I found some chips on the edges of the bat so i'm sure it was plaster that got into the clay.
I have about 4 bags of reclaimed clay that could be contaminated and I don't want to use this to make anything important in case of pop outs. I've heard it's unlikely that they would cause explosions in the kiln but rather just cracks and chips after the piece has been fired, sometimes after months even?
I've also heard that if the plaster specs are small enough it won't cause a problem, and thought about putting the slaked clay through an 80 mesh sieve before reclaiming? Would using an immersion blender also work in the same way?
I'll put the soft plaster bat inside of a pillowcase until I have chance to make a better one. I'm thinking i'll just use the reclaimed clay as an excuse to make myself something, and for test tiles and bisque moulds.