For me form is always primary, if the form is not there than function or surface doesn't really matter.
If there is a mug or a teapot with an unpleasing form, would you still want to purchase or use it even if the glaze (surface) is perfect? Of course pleasing or unpleasing is in the eye of the beholder.
Now if you have a beautiful form along with a beautiful surface you have a winner.
- Pres likes this