I get that a well rounded technical knowledge of all things pottery is helpful in understanding and correcting errors but I think it is a lot more than that in the long run.
Understanding the Raku process as well as the many other possible processes and approaches, regardless of whether you employ them provides competence of craft. It opens up choices and options at each point in the process. The more knowledge, the more techniques mastered, the broader the approach can be to getting where one wants as an artisan (or artist if that's your thing).
Doing a piece a certain way because you think that will bring out the best in a piece is a lot different than doing the piece the only way you know how.
I think that holds true even if the latter turns out to be a wonderful piece.
The one thing that stands out to me when defining experience by number of years is that it is really all over the board how much experience that is. I think there are very serious people that work in their studios regularly, even daily, accumulating less experience over 5, even 10 years than a new, really dedicated, full timer working really hard might put in in a year or two.
It also seems to really matter what the objectives are as that is going to really shape the experience accumulated.
Thanks again Mark for the input, was greatly appreciated. A shout out to George Ullrich at Sheffield Pottery, he helped me source Ceramical on the west coast so I was able to go with it without having to pay three times the cost.
Shipping 1 or 2 50lb bags around the country can sure get expensive.
Our PayPal here account works a little differently than above. When a card is swiped the money goes to our business PayPal account. We can transfer that money to our bank account, spend it directly using the PayPal account with PayPal checkout online or an added a debit card. We declined the debit card and just move the money to our bank account. You may be able to have it go automatically, I'm not sure but definitely with a click when your logged in. Also does a lot of customer management for credit and cash purchases and generates tax reports and such.
I have not used Square but I have heard that the money may well get to your bank a day or so faster with Square but with PayPal there is a way to have instant access to some or all of that money. So as usual there are pros and cons top both services.
Another reason we chose PayPal is that you can actually talk to a person if you need to and I hear it is hard to get that level of service with Square.
I see a lot of postings around where folks like to setup both of these services and then run cards based on their particular circumstances and to have a backup if there is a problem.
Sounds like you have not actually sat down and had a really direct conversation with your studio mate on this issue. I get that you resisted offering help and then really said "no" but have you actually spent some time discussing this with her. I am trying to see your side and I understand you feel violated but I'm not sure I see a solution that will not require some compromise on your part as well.
You have a paper clay process that you use on some of your work that took you a long time to perfect. She is at a stage where she feels she needs to use a paper clay process on an aspect of her work. She asked you for your help and you declined because it took you a long time to develop your process, fair enough. At this point she started experimenting on her own and you feel she is mimicking your process.
Is she doing this by observing you do it or just looking at your finished work? Are you positive she is not doing her own R&D?
What do you want her to do exactly? As Babs suggested, maybe ask for a meeting between you and her and a neutral person from the studio and lay out your case and try and convince her you are right and she should not use your process on her work. ( I like the wine suggestion )
She's doing this because she feels she needs to for her work and she likely feels it is OK. She is probably not going to stop and you are just going to get more and more angry. A straight up conversation about it would at least clear the air and you both would come away knowing how the other feels about the situation and that's half way toward a solution right there. Perhaps there is a compromise that can be worked out. One key thing is that this not about you and its not about her, its about both of you and the solution has to work for both of you.
I would also suggest standing back a little and truly try to evaluate your work and make sure your feelings are justified. Is this a process that you personally came up with and is truly unique or one that is common that just took a lot of time and research to connect the dots and learn how to do. There are a lot of very cool processes out there that have been around for eons and just being the first to adapt them in a studio or geographic area does not mean other artist shouldn't pursue them as well.
I guess I am saying make sure you are not trying to assume ownership of a process that is not yours.
Whatever you do, don't spend wonderful studio time being angry and try not to mess up her time as well.
I looked up a number of the artist and enjoyed looking at other work they have done, maybe some of you would like some of their other work.
Some of these artist simply work with clay as a medium and have not and probably will never will work on making beautiful dinnerware or other functional pottery. I like all kinds of ceramic art as well as beautifully crafted functional ware but I think there is such little synergy between the work in this article and functional ware that it is extremely hard to compare them.
Hi Bob, I certainly was not offended at all. I think Colby just got a bit emotional is all.
I do think Colby makes some strong arguments that once you move away from mimicking forms or expressions loosely or with exactness then you hit a place in art where stirred emotions or intent starts to weigh in.
Almost anyone can take up a potters wheel, pick up a paint brush or start carving sculpturesand with enough instruction and enough hours practice become pretty damned accomplished. I get that the ones that stick with traditional forms and work within the confines of a familiar range (a vase looks like a vase) are the ones you like and assign value to BUT that work is just part of what's out there and those that are not making traditional vases, painting realistic landscapes or carving lifelike bust are creating really meaningful work that is really worth the 'work' you mentioned earlier to try and understand.
I do hope you come across something at some point that drives the point home because I think it will be an Aha moment for you, it was for me.
I'm going to leave it at that as well and I hope I also did not offend anyone.
I guess I am missing the point. If a 6 year old is interested in pottery and his dad wants to encourage this, why not start him off with pottery equipment and tools instead ad hoc stuff? Banding wheels are not for throwing pots and it just seems he is going to probably spend most of his time annoyed with the equipment and likely lose interest in the whole thing.
Ya know, I would say try and think of recycled clay as a bonus and just go with the flow when it does not work out. At the end of the day you're reclaiming all that can be reclaimed and keeping waste to a minimum and that's really what its all about, right?
Maybe just hold it to the side and use it when you are experimenting with a new form or use it up making a round of new garden pots for your personal use.
I am learning to just go with it when things go wrong as issues just seem to pop up at the most inopportune times, don't let it take away your Zen :-)